Navigating the Uncertainty: Transparency in Institutional Need-Based Aid Amidst FAFSA and ISIR Delays

March 07, 2024

n the highly competitive landscape of higher education, where colleges and universities strive to be the top choice for admitted students, a shared commitment to the transformative power of education unites professionals in the industry. However, amidst delays in FAFSA and ISIR data, a pressing issue has emerged - the secrecy surrounding institutional plans for packaging need-based aid.

The Dilemma: To Wait or Act?

Since the Department of Education's announcement that ISIR data won't be available until mid-March, higher ed administrators face a complex decision. The dilemma is whether to wait for official ISIR data before packaging institutional need-based aid or to adapt strategies and issue estimated packages before the March data release. For some, this means launching new aid applications during an already tumultuous cycle, utilizing tools like the CSS Profile Lite, Slate forms, or homegrown apps.

Communication Gap: Secrecy and Missed Opportunities

In a scan of college websites and social media, a significant number do not disclose their plans regarding the FAFSA and ISIR delays. Some institutions opt for a more discreet approach, inviting admitted students via email and online portals to fill out new financial aid forms. It raises questions about whether some schools are yet to update their websites or if there is a strategic advantage in keeping their new aid application method undisclosed.

The lack of clear communication with prospective students represents a missed opportunity for institutions and potentially harms the students they aim to serve. We advocate for a clear, consistent message across all communication channels, emphasizing the need for transparency, especially on institutional websites.

The Need for Transparency: A Confusing Admission Cycle

In a typical admission cycle, students apply to multiple schools, each with unique deadlines and packaging timelines. The varying institutional responses to FAFSA delays and methods for collecting needed information only add confusion. Transparency becomes crucial, and college websites serve as vital sources for up-to-date information. Without clear communication, responses to supplemental aid applications may be stifled, leaving students in the dark.

Collective Knowledge: Beneficial for Institutions and Students

Transparency is not only beneficial to prospective students but also to the higher education community at large. Shared knowledge about industry developments empowers institutions to make informed decisions. This collective approach ensures that students receive the necessary information to make informed choices about their college journey.

FAFSA Delays: Impact on At-Risk Families

First-generation and low-income families are particularly at risk of being negatively affected by FAFSA delays. Many families, especially those with low income, cannot make enrollment decisions until they see a full aid package, including state and federal aid. While more families may qualify for Pell grants this year, awareness of these awards will come much later in the cycle than usual. To prevent a cohort of first-generation and low-income students from bearing the brunt of Department of Education mistakes, it is crucial to keep these families well-informed about the FAFSA and awarding process.

Guiding Families Through Complexity

As an industry, it is our responsibility to guide families through the complexity of the FAFSA and awarding process. Offering clear guidance and ensuring that information about timelines and unique packaging circumstances is readily available online is essential. Together, through transparency and collaboration, we can navigate the uncertainties caused by FAFSA and ISIR delays and ensure that students receive the support they need to make informed decisions about their higher education journey.

Looking for help? Let's get in touch!